My Experience with the Best Meal Replacement Shake to Lose Weight for Women Over 40

Several years ago I would have never imagined my decision to drink a meal replacement shake to lose weight would lead me to this point in my life. Perhaps like you, I wasn’t sure I could be satisfied with a meal replacement shake instead of a cheeseburger from Sonic. However, looking back, a meal replacement that is nutritionally a full meal was the catalyst to my weight loss.

Drinking the right meal replacement shake with protein is the foundation for weight loss, building muscle and maintaining good health.

I can credit meal replacement shakes 100% with my weight loss. Had I not had the jumpstart and motivation, I can’t say for sure I would be doing what I am today. 

stephanie making protein shake with 1st phorm protein

I was an overweight 41-year-old woman who had never had to work very hard at losing weight…until after 40. After my hysterectomy, my weight began to increase rapidly.

Once I made the decision to lose weight, I knew my eating habits had to change. The frequent fast food stops, the processed food, and desserts needed to be traded for healthy meals.

At the time, I only knew how to cook foods high in calories and I knew time spent in the kitchen would only lead me to eat those foods I had come to love but not need. My go-to foods were almost all simple carbs that would not support weight loss goals.

level 1 meal replacement jug of protein powder

I had never tried losing weight with a meal replacement shake before. Knowing how much I loved eating, I have to admit I was a bit skeptical.

It took a couple of weeks to transition to satisfy my hunger with a drinkable shake, but once I did, a domino effect began to happen.

best meal replacement shake for weight loss - strawberry protein shake with strawberries beside glass and powder on top of meal replacement shake that helps women lose weight

How I Started Loving Meal Replacement Shakes

First, the meal replacement shake tasted great. I have always loved chocolate, and the Chocolate flavor is like drinking a treat. The shake quickly replaced my need for a daily sweet treat and I was happily having 2 – 3 shakes a day.

This meal replacement has so much fiber it makes it extremely filling.

Sometimes I would have it alongside a little bit of food as I transitioned to only having the shake for a meal. It’s true, sometimes you just need to chew on food to feel like you’re eating in the early transition period.

In the evening, during my usual after dinner dessert or snack time, I would instead have a shake. I allowed myself some of what I craved but also worked in a shake, helping me to reduce my food portion size.

The transition to full meal replacements and healthy eating was driven by both my goals and my cravings. Meaning, I didn’t force myself too hard to change overnight.

This kind of slower transition led to more success than if I had stopped everything I was accustomed to eating overnight.

I never felt like I was forcing myself to drink meal replacements instead of a plate of food. I think that is really important to note.

I had meal replacement shakes for weight loss because I wanted to put good, healthy nutrients in my body and at the time, a protein supplement loaded with vitamins and fiber was the way to do it.

level 1 meal replacement jug of protein powder

How many calories are in a meal replacement?

The calories in the meal replacement shakes are about 150 calories using water.

Sometimes I create a smoothie with them but most of the time it’s a grab and go with a little crushed ice and water. The shakes tastes so good, they don’t have to have anything added!

What makes this shake different?

The key to losing weight after 40 is cutting back the snacking on junk food (ie: sugar and other simple carbs) we have become accustomed to eating. Plus, somewhere along the way, we started the emotional eating which is a really hard habit to break.

The meal replacement shakes are loaded with fiber and other nutrients we need.

The fiber is one of the components for filling us up and satisfying our hunger for longer periods of time, perfect for replacing a meal.

Also in the shake is high in protein, 25 grams, another bonus. Protein is essential for rebuilding and toning muscles that we have lost over the years. When we tone our muscles, metabolism increases, therefore we burn more calories throughout the day.

Healthy protein shakes are the foundation for millions of people wanting to live a healthy life today. What used to be a bodybuilder’s supplement has become a household standard for people of all ages and goals.

My teenaged daughter was so concerned for me when I began drinking the meal replacement shakes for weight loss instead of eating what she considered real food. My meal replacement drinks were so much healthier than the food she was eating!

When choosing good protein shakes like this one, you can feel good about drinking it because it is packed with vitamins and minerals your body needs daily.

This truly is not an ordinary meal replacement shake. I stayed on the meal replacement shakes now for over 8 years.

While I know there are a lot of good quality protein shakes available, the best meal replacement shake for weight loss is still 1st Phorm. Once you feel more comfortable with smaller portions, the 8 grams of fiber may not be as needed as it was in the beginning.

There are some great meal replacements on the market, but for weight loss, the 1st Phorm Protein Shake is the entire package needed by women over 40.

Are Meal Replacement Shakes Good for Weight Loss

So many women tell me drinking shakes aren’t satisfying; the need for eating and chewing is still there.

I totally understand. It was an adjustment period for me too. There were days in the beginning when I would have my shake with a little bit of food. It’s okay to add a shake to a small meal as you learn to adapt.

The meal replacements should never be the only thing you have during the day. Protein shakes are beneficial for weight loss, toning muscles and improving health.

level 1 meal replacement jug of protein powder

The average person doesn’t eat enough lean protein, especially when trying to lose weight and tone muscles. It can be difficult to eat enough lean protein without adding too many calories – which is where a protein shake or meal replacement shake is needed.

For more information on drinking protein shakes regularly for weight loss, make sure to read this post on Protein for Weight Loss. The difference between this meal replacement shake and other protein powder is mainly the amount of fiber.

You can even use the meal replacement for snacks! Snacks and eating ENOUGH is important to better health including losing weight.

Chances are, your snacks often end up being more than 200 calories, and empty calories even! Isn’t it better to have a snack loaded with vitamins, protein, and fiber?

I think yes!

strawberry weight loss shakes with fresh strawberries beside glass

Once I became accustomed to drinking a shake for a meal, I usually had one for breakfast, lunch and sometimes a snack. Dinner would be healthy with protein and vegetables.

After I was able to have a kick start of losing weight with meal replacement shakes, it motivated me to work harder. I worked out harder, made better choices with food and stayed consistent.

What I am drinking now

I highly recommend all of the members of the Fit Found Me Weight Loss Challenges to supplement with protein powder daily to meet their protein goals. Without a good quality supplement, it would be very difficult to eat the right amount of protein our body needs. 

Even if it’s only as a snack or post-workout protein drink, the fiber and protein are great for good health and will help you reach your goals.

Protein shakes are still a regular part of my nutrition. Making sure to meet my protein macros every day helps maintain muscle tone. 

Now, I prefer the 1st Phorm protein supplements because of the quality of the processing and manufacturing retains a higher quality protein. It is processed in a low heat which holds more nutrients, therefore it is better for digestion and usage. 

Have you tried a meal replacement shake to lose weight before?

meal replacement shake in a glass with strawberries

Meal Replacement Shake for Women’s Weight Loss

Published By Stephanie
This was my go-to for a meal replacement shake for a long time. It's easy to substitute your favorite fruits and play around with the different combination of flavors.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 5 mins
Total Time 5 mins
Course Main Course, Snack
Cuisine American
Servings 1 servings
Calories 261 kcal


  • blender


  • 1 scoop Level-1, Vanilla
  • ½ cup ice
  • 6 oz water
  • 1 cup strawberries
  • ½ cup blueberries
  • 1 cup Kale


  • Put all ingredients into blender.
  • Blend until smooth.
  • Enjoy!


Serving: 1glassCalories: 261kcalCarbohydrates: 35gProtein: 28gFat: 3gSaturated Fat: 1gSodium: 42mgPotassium: 606mgFiber: 5gSugar: 17gVitamin A: 6693IUVitamin C: 172mgCalcium: 124mgIron: 2mg
Keyword Healthy
Tried this recipe?Tag me on Facebook @fitfoundme with a pic and let me know what you thought of this recipe in the comments below!

level 1 meal replacement jug of protein powder

Additional Shake Info:

Everything You Need to Know to Effectively Use Protein for Weight Loss

Nutrition for weight loss can be a tricky thing to learn when transitioning to a healthy lifestyle. Eating enough lean protein for weight loss can be the trickiest. Consuming too little can lead to a weight loss plateau.

No doubt, protein for weight loss could, in fact, be the link you’ve been missing.  As women over 40 embarking on our first real journey of sustainable weight loss, fitness and overall good health, there can be a lot to learn.

For a Vegan Shake to Lose Weight:

Trying to Lose Weight? You Should Be Drinking This Protein Shake Even If You Aren’t Vegan

Call me crazy, but this whey protein loving girl is going vegan! Okay, well, not quite, but I just drank fermented vegan proteins shake…and I liked it! Eeeeek!

about stephanie

About Stephanie

Just an everyday stay at home mom who one day decided I didn’t want to become the stereotypical overweight, middle-aged, out of breath, mom anymore. One day at a time, one meal at a time, one workout at a time and I became the athlete I never knew existed. Read more...

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

5 stars

How/ where can i get the GNC meal replacement?

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x