Skip to Content

Wisconsin Dairy Queen puts up ‘politically incorrect’ sign, owner stands by his decision

In the quaint town of Kewaskum, Wisconsin, a local Dairy Queen franchise ignited a heated national debate when it displayed a controversial sign on its door. The sign, deemed “politically incorrect” by many, boldly declared support for traditional Judeo-Christian values and American patriotism. The sign’s content, which included phrases like “Merry Christmas,” “Happy Easter,” and “In God We Trust,” alongside an offer of free ice cream to veterans, sparked both fervent support and vehement criticism, turning this small-town Dairy Queen into a focal point for discussions on the intersection of personal beliefs and business practices.

This incident, which began in 2017, underscores a larger conversation about the role of personal values in the workplace and their implications for businesses. Owner Kevin Scheunemann’s steadfast defense of the sign, despite backlash, highlights the complex dynamics between maintaining one’s values and managing public perception. As society grapples with the balance between inclusivity and expression of beliefs, this Dairy Queen controversy offers a compelling case study on how personal convictions can influence consumer sentiment and business identity.

The Bold Declaration

In 2017, the Dairy Queen franchise in Kewaskum, Wisconsin, became embroiled in controversy due to a sign displayed on its door. Featuring phrases like “Merry Christmas,” “Happy Easter,” “In God We Trust,” and an offer of free ice cream to veterans, the sign was intended to reflect owner Kevin Scheunemann’s personal values of faith and patriotism. This bold declaration quickly polarized public opinion. Supporters lauded the sign for celebrating traditional American values and honoring religious holidays, seeing it as a stand against what they perceived as an increasingly secular society. They believed it fostered a sense of community and patriotism. Critics, however, viewed the sign as exclusionary and potentially alienating to non-Christian customers. They argued that it could make patrons who do not share the same religious beliefs feel unwelcome, thus creating an uninviting atmosphere for a diverse customer base. This tension highlighted a broader national debate about the role of religion in public spaces and businesses, balancing personal beliefs with inclusivity for all customers. Despite the backlash, Scheunemann stood firm, framing the sign as an honest representation of the establishment’s values. He argued that transparency about the business’s core principles was crucial for maintaining its integrity. This incident underscores the complexities businesses face when personal beliefs intersect with public perception, illustrating the challenges and potential consequences of navigating the politically charged landscape of personal and public values.

Navigating Politically Correctness

The controversy surrounding the Dairy Queen sign in Kewaskum highlights the complex relationship between personal beliefs, business identity, and consumer sentiment. The sign’s polarizing nature drew national attention, illustrating the challenges businesses face when their values enter the public discourse. For some, the sign affirmed shared beliefs and values, fostering solidarity and loyalty among like-minded customers who appreciated the owner’s willingness to express his faith and patriotism openly. Conversely, the sign attracted significant criticism for being insensitive and exclusionary. Critics argued that businesses in a diverse society should create inclusive environments that welcome all customers, regardless of their personal beliefs. They contended that the sign could alienate non-Christian patrons or those who do not celebrate the mentioned holidays, posing a risk to the Dairy Queen’s broader customer base. This aspect of the controversy underscores the potential pitfalls for businesses that choose to take a public stand on religious or political issues. From a business perspective, the Dairy Queen incident illustrates the importance of evaluating the potential impacts of public declarations on consumer sentiment and brand perception. Research indicates that belief-driven consumers, particularly millennials and Generation Z, favor companies that align with their social, political, and personal values. However, this alignment can be a double-edged sword. While it can foster strong loyalty and engagement from certain demographics, it can also repel others. Companies must carefully consider their core values and the potential ramifications of publicly expressing them. A well-thought-out crisis management plan is essential for mitigating negative fallout and navigating the complex landscape of public opinion and consumer expectations.

Legal Battles and Family Feuds

The public response to the Dairy Queen sign in Kewaskum not only sparked a heated debate but also underscored the potential legal and social ramifications businesses face when expressing personal beliefs in a public setting. While no formal legal action was taken against the Dairy Queen franchise, the incident raised questions about the boundaries of free speech in the workplace and the legal implications of displaying religious and political messages in a business environment. Legal experts note that while business owners have the right to express their beliefs, they must also consider anti-discrimination laws and the potential for lawsuits if customers or employees feel they are being excluded or marginalized based on those beliefs. The sign also led to intense public discourse, reflecting broader societal divides and fueling family feuds among patrons with differing viewpoints. Some families and community members found themselves at odds over the support or criticism of the Dairy Queen’s stance, leading to strained relationships and heated arguments. This aspect of the controversy highlights how deeply personal and divisive such issues can become, affecting not just the business but the social fabric of the community. The emotional and psychological impact on individuals and families caught in the crossfire of such debates can be significant, often resulting in long-lasting rifts and a polarized community environment.

Managing Controversy: Practical Tips for Business Owners

The Dairy Queen controversy in Kewaskum highlights the challenges businesses face when personal beliefs intersect with public perception. Here are some practical tips and strategies for business owners to manage such situations effectively:

  • Seek Professional Advice: Consulting with public relations experts, legal advisors, and financial professionals is essential. They can help create a comprehensive plan that addresses immediate public relations needs, long-term reputation management, legal implications, and financial stability.
  • Create a Crisis Management Plan: Establishing a crisis management plan helps in managing public relations and ensures responses align with overall business values and goals. A structured approach prevents missteps and maintains public trust.
  • Diversify Communication Channels: Using various communication channels, including social media, press releases, and community engagement, promotes a balanced narrative. Diversification helps in reaching different audience segments effectively.
  • Engage with Community Feedback: Listening to and addressing community feedback can improve public perception. Engaging constructively with critics and showing a willingness to understand diverse viewpoints can foster community support.
  • Establish a Reputation Management Fund: Setting aside funds for reputation management is crucial. This fund should cover potential costs related to legal defenses, public relations campaigns, and community outreach programs, providing a financial cushion in case of significant public relations challenges.
  • Understand Legal Implications: Knowing the legal implications of public statements and actions is vital. Working with legal professionals can help in planning for and minimizing legal liabilities, such as compliance with public accommodation laws and avoiding discriminatory practices.
  • Protect Business Assets: Ensuring proper insurance coverage for the business, including liability and public relations insurance, is important to protect assets. Insurance provides a safety net against potential losses and unforeseen circumstances arising from public controversies.
  • Consider Philanthropic Engagement: Engaging in philanthropic activities can improve public perception and provide tax benefits. Establishing community programs or making regular contributions to local causes can be part of a broader reputation management plan.
  • Maintain a Balanced Public Image: Sudden public attention can lead to drastic changes in public image, which may not always be sustainable. Maintaining a balanced public image and avoiding excessive reactive measures ensures long-term reputation health and community well-being.
  • Regularly Review and Adjust Strategies: Reputation management is an ongoing process. Regularly reviewing and adjusting strategies with the help of professionals ensures the business’s public image remains aligned with changing public expectations and market conditions.

By following these practical tips and strategies, business owners can effectively manage public controversies, ensuring both financial stability and positive public perception while safeguarding their future.

Final Thoughts

The Dairy Queen controversy in Kewaskum serves as a poignant example of the intricate balance businesses must strike between expressing personal beliefs and maintaining inclusivity. Owner Kevin Scheunemann’s decision to display a sign reflecting his faith and patriotism ignited a national debate, highlighting the potential risks and rewards of taking a public stand on contentious issues. While the sign resonated with some customers, fostering a sense of community and loyalty, it also alienated others, underscoring the fine line between personal expression and public business practices. This incident emphasizes the importance of transparency and the need for businesses to be mindful of the diverse perspectives within their customer base. Companies must carefully consider how their values align with those of their customers and the broader community. Implementing a robust crisis management plan and regularly reviewing the impacts of such decisions can help mitigate potential backlash and ensure long-term success.Ultimately, the Dairy Queen sign controversy underscores the complexities of navigating politically charged landscapes in the business world. It serves as a reminder that while taking a stand can strengthen brand loyalty among certain demographics, it also carries significant risks. Businesses must weigh these factors carefully to maintain their integrity and foster an inclusive environment for all customers. By learning from such examples, companies can better navigate the challenges of integrating personal beliefs with professional responsibilities, ensuring they remain respectful and inclusive in their practices.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.